Selecting a kitty litter scoop is a lot like shopping for a car. Consider cornering ability, maneuverability, load capacity, body style and materials, height/depth, cost … kick the tires, and take it for a spin!
Cornering: Does your litter box have square corners or rounded corners? Select the style of scoop that more tightly fits the litter box corners, so when you’re chasing down those lumps, the tight fit at the corners keeps the smaller clumps from slipping back into the box.
Maneuverability: What’s the overall length of the scoop you’re considering, compared to the width and length (and height) of the litter box? If the scoop length is greater than the width of the litter box, and the sides of the box are a bit high, scoop maneuverability may be limited when the scoop handle hits the sides of the litter box.
Materials: Most litter scoops are made of one of these:
- flimsy plastic
- hard, substantive plastic
- medium plastic
- metal (probably painted)
- metal and rubber
Flimsy plastic works alright if you don’t have to scrape stuck-on clumps off of the litter box, or pick up anything very heavy. For my purposes, they break fairly fast, and aren’t worth the cheap price. Probably have square corners.
Medium weight plastic scoops are the most easily found, and may suffice under most circumstances, and last for years; but you cannot apply a lot of pressure to stuck-on clumps of clay litter. Probably square cornered. I’ve seen these in both the usual size and the larger one, in blue plastic – Walmart has them.
The hard, substantial plastic scoops, such as those at Petco, are some of the best overall scoops. The ones I have, have rounded corners. They’re great scoops, and some of my favorites, but the handles are so long that they sometimes have maneuverability issues in litter boxes with higher sides. May 2019 update: these are falling out of favor with me. The handle snapped off of one for no apparent reason. After years of using a second one, it’s becoming increasingly annoying that the size and configuration of the holes in the scoop traps good litter above the clumped litter and I’m throwing out usable litter with the bad. As a workaround, sometimes I dump the scoop back into the litter box and re-scoop it. Save yourself the trouble, and either go with the economical medium-weight blue plastic scoops available at Walmart and other stores, or the heavy-weight metal and rubber (see below).
Plain all-metal scoops. These are similar in design to the lightweight and medium weight plastics scoops, but probably the best overall for chiseling stuck litter clumps off of the litter box, because the metal edge is narrower and sharper than the metal on the larger and heavier metal scoops. Modestly priced, but those I have are small in capacity, with low sides, and the clumps fall back into the litter box, making for a lot of trips with the scoop.
Larger, heavier metal scoops with rubber handles. I recommend if you come across these in a store, hold it in your hand as you would when using it. On some of them, the metal fills the rubber handle only about halfway, which just feels awkward. Find the kind where the metal fills the rubber handle almost all the way. These probably all have rounded corners. Some of these are great – the best I’ve found.
Size of holes: The holes of the scoop tend to become partially clogged with damp or sticky litter. If they’re very small to begin with, then you wind up having to shake them back and forth to get the loose litter to fall through.
Carrying capacity: Carrying capacity is determined by both the “footprint” of the scoop, and its depth. Smaller scoops or those that are shallow with low sides don’t hold enough for my purposes. They fill quickly, clumps fall out over the sides, and a lot of scooping is required to clean a litter box. I like the larger size, with plenty of depth.
Pidge’s choice? The larger, deeper scoops made of heavy material – the metal with the rubber handle (preferably where the metal inside the rubber handle extends the full length).
Photos to be added asap!